Scriptural Savant

Home / Scripture / Book of Mormon / Alma

Alma 57

Two Hundred Who Fainted, Not One Who Fell — Exactness, Faith, and the Keeping of the Sons

Alma 57: Helaman's epistle continues, recounting events of the twenty-eighth and twenty-ninth years of the reign of the judges (the letter itself was received by Moroni in the thirtieth — Helaman is still looking back). Ammoron offers to surrender Antiparah in exchange for the prisoners; Helaman refuses any but an even exchange, and the people of Antiparah abandon the city, which falls into Nephite hands. Reinforced by six thousand men and sixty more sons of the Ammonites — so that the two thousand are now two thousand and sixty — Helaman's army surrounds and takes the city of Cumeni by intercepting its provisions, then holds it against a fierce Lamanite counterattack. The prisoners grow so numerous and so violent that, when they rebel and rush the guards, the Nephites are forced to slay many. In the climactic battle for Cumeni, Helaman's young men fight 'most desperately,' firm and undaunted, obeying every word of command 'with exactness,' and 'according to their faith it was done unto them.' When it is over, two hundred of the two thousand and sixty have fainted from loss of blood, and every one of them has been wounded many times — yet not one soul of them has perished, a preservation Helaman and his whole army 'justly ascribe... to the miraculous power of God.' This is the war record's deepest meditation on the kind of deliverance faith brings: not exemption from wounds, but preservation through them.

Open printable insert (PDF) ↗Scripture only →

Witnesses on the page:Helaman son of Alma,The Stripling Warriors

Where we are

Alma 57 continues Helaman's letter without a break, and it raises the stakes of the miracle that closed Alma 56. There, two thousand untried sons fought the strongest Lamanite army and not one of them died — and a reader might, just possibly, file it under extraordinary good fortune. Alma 57 makes that filing impossible. Because this time the sons are not spared the fighting's cost. This time every one of them is wounded, two hundred of them faint from loss of blood, the battle is so desperate that the rest of the army is about to give way — and still not one of them perishes. The chapter is constructed to move the miracle from the category of luck into the category of God, by showing a preservation that survives the most punishing possible test. In Alma 56 the sons came through untouched; one could imagine a natural explanation. In Alma 57 they come through shredded — bleeding, fainting, wounded many times over — and the survival of every single one of them through that is something no natural account can carry. Helaman names it for what it is: we do justly ascribe it to the miraculous power of God (v. 26).

And the chapter adds a second element that Alma 56 only implied: the exactness of the sons' obedience. They did obey and observe to perform every word of command with exactness; yea, and even according to their faith it was done unto them (v. 21). This is the doctrinal hinge of the whole stripling-warrior account, and it is easy to read past. Helaman is telling Moroni why these young men were what they were, and he names two things welded together: their faith and their exactness. They trusted God completely, and they obeyed completely — and the two were not separate virtues but one. According to their faith it was done unto them is the principle Christ himself will state centuries later (according to your faith be it unto you, Matt. 9:29); Helaman has discovered it on a battlefield. The sons' faith was not a feeling that left them passive; it expressed itself as flawless, exact, trusting obedience to every command — and that exact obedience was the very channel through which the promised deliverance flowed.

But the chapter is honest, and its honesty is part of its weight. It does not pretend that righteous war is clean. The prisoners rebel and have to be killed; Antipus is dead; a thousand of our brethren are slain (v. 26); the army suffers great loss (v. 23). Helaman sets the preservation of his two thousand and sixty against a backdrop of real death and real horror, and he does not soften either. The sons are kept — but they are kept inside a war that is killing many, not lifted out of it. That is the precise shape of the deliverance the chapter teaches.

The chapter has four movements.

  1. Antiparah falls; the army reinforced (vv. 1–6). Helaman refuses Ammoron's offer to trade Antiparah for prisoners; the city is abandoned and falls to the Nephites; six thousand men and sixty more Ammonite sons arrive, making the band two thousand and sixty.
  2. Cumeni taken and held (vv. 7–17). The Nephites surround Cumeni and starve it of provisions until it yields; the prisoners grow so numerous and violent that many must be slain; a Lamanite counterattack nearly overwhelms them.
  3. The sons stand, and the miracle (vv. 18–27). Helaman's two thousand and sixty fight firm and undaunted, obeying with exactness, and according to their faith are delivered; two hundred faint from loss of blood and all are wounded, yet not one perishes — ascribed to the miraculous power of God.
  4. Gid's report (vv. 28–36). Gid recounts how the prisoners being escorted to Zarahemla rebelled and rushed the swords and were slain or scattered, and how his band returned in time to help save Cumeni; Helaman rejoices in God's preserving goodness.

The verses that carry the chapter are these. Verse 21 names the doctrine — they did obey and observe to perform every word of command with exactness; yea... according to their faith it was done unto them. Verse 25 names the cost-bearing miracle — two hundred, out of my two thousand and sixty, who had fainted because of the loss of blood; nevertheless... there was not one soul of them who did perish. Verse 26 names its source — we do justly ascribe it to the miraculous power of God, because of their exceeding faith. And verse 27 names their character — they are young, and their minds are firm, and they do put their trust in God continually. The chapter exists to show that the deliverance faith brings is not freedom from wounds but preservation through them, and that the faith which is so preserved shows itself as exact, trusting obedience.

The cost the chapter will not hide (verses 1–17)

For behold, they would break out in great numbers, and would fight with stones, and with clubs, or whatsoever thing they could get into their hands, insomuch that we did slay upwards of two thousand of them after they had surrendered themselves prisoners of war. — Alma 57:14

Before the chapter reaches its miracle, it makes us walk through its horror, and the placement is deliberate. The taking of Cumeni is a success — surrounded, starved of its provisions, the city yields without, it seems, a pitched assault (v. 12). But the success creates a problem that has no clean solution: prisoners, so numerous that... we were obliged to employ all our force to keep them, or to put them to death (v. 13). And when the prisoners rebel — rushing the guards with stones and clubs and bare hands — the Nephites kill upwards of two thousand of them after they had surrendered (v. 14). Helaman records it plainly, without justification or anguish, because it is simply what happened: an army with too many prisoners, too few provisions, and an enemy at the gates had no way to hold rebelling captives except to kill them. This is not the bloodless mercy of Gid. This is the other face of war, the face that even a righteous cause cannot always avoid, and Helaman does not pretend otherwise.

It matters that the chapter shows us this before it shows us the preservation of the sons, because it inoculates the miracle against sentimentality. A reader tempted to think that faith makes war pretty, or that God's people pass through battle untouched by its grimness, is shown two thousand surrendered men cut down out of sheer impossibility. The world Helaman's sons are kept in is this world — a world of starvation, rebellion, and forced killing, where Antipus lies dead and a thousand of our brethren will fall before the chapter ends. The miracle of the unkilled sons does not float above that reality; it happens inside it. And that is the only kind of miracle worth testifying to — not one that pretends the horror away, but one that keeps the faithful through a horror it does not deny.

Exactness, and faith made obedience (verses 18–24)

Yea, and they did obey and observe to perform every word of command with exactness; yea, and even according to their faith it was done unto them; and I did remember the words which they said unto me that their mothers had taught them. — Alma 57:21

Here is the chapter's doctrinal center, and it deserves slow reading, because it corrects a misunderstanding of faith that has dogged believers in every age. We might imagine that the sons' faith was a feeling — a warm confidence, an inward serenity — and that their deliverance was a reward dropped on them from outside for having the feeling. Helaman says something far more demanding. Their faith expressed itself as obedience, and not vague obedience but exact obedience: they did obey and observe to perform every word of command with exactness. Every word. With exactness. These untried youths did precisely what they were told, precisely when and how they were told, holding formation, executing each order without deviation, in the chaos of a battle that was breaking the men around them. And Helaman ties this exactness directly to their faith and to their deliverance in a single breath: with exactness; yea, and even according to their faith it was done unto them.

The phrase according to their faith it was done unto them is one of the great formulas of scripture, and Helaman arrives at it independently of the Gospels where Christ will speak it (according to your faith be it unto you, Matt. 9:29; as thou hast believed, so be it done unto thee, Matt. 8:13). The principle is that the measure of the deliverance answers to the measure of the faith — and that the faith in question is not a passive state but an active trust that obeys. The sons believed God would deliver them; that belief did not make them reckless or idle; it made them exact. Their trust took the form of doing every commanded thing perfectly, because they trusted the One in whose cause the commands were given. This welds together two things often torn apart — faith and works, trust and obedience — and shows them as a single reality. The sons' exactness was their faith in action; their faith was their willingness to obey without hedging. And it was through that exact, obedient faith that the promise of their mothers was kept: according to their faith it was done unto them. Notice Helaman's tender aside in the same verse — I did remember the words which they said unto me that their mothers had taught them. In the heat of the battle, watching these boys obey with such trusting precision, Helaman's mind goes back to we do not doubt our mothers knew it. The exactness on the field and the faith taught at home are, to him, the same thing seen twice.

Two hundred fainted, not one fell (verses 25–27)

And it came to pass that there were two hundred, out of my two thousand and sixty, who had fainted because of the loss of blood; nevertheless, according to the goodness of God, and to our great astonishment, and also the joy of our whole army, there was not one soul of them who did perish; yea, and neither was there one soul among them who had not received many wounds. — Alma 57:25

This is the verse the whole chapter is built to deliver, and its power lies in a paradox it states without flinching: two hundred... fainted because of the loss of blood... yet there was not one soul of them who did perish... neither was there one soul among them who had not received many wounds. Every clause matters. They were not untouched — every one was wounded, and wounded many times. Two hundred of them bled until they fainted, drained to the edge of death. The deliverance Helaman testifies to is emphatically not an exemption from suffering. The sons were cut, pierced, battered, bled white. And still — through all of it, against every probability, with two hundred of them unconscious from blood loss — not one of them died.

This is a more profound testimony than Alma 56's, and Helaman, who has pondered it for years, knows it. In Alma 56 the sons came through clean, and the miracle could be doubted. Here they come through broken — and the survival of every single one through wounds that should have killed many is something the natural world cannot produce. Two hundred men do not faint from blood loss and all live; an army does not take many wounds apiece and lose none. The arithmetic is impossible, and Helaman names the only adequate cause: we do justly ascribe it to the miraculous power of God, because of their exceeding faith in that which they had been taught to believe — that there was a just God, and whosoever did not doubt, that they should be preserved by his marvelous power (v. 26). Read that explanation carefully, because it defines exactly what the mothers' promise meant and did not mean. It did not mean you will not be wounded. It did not mean you will not suffer. It meant you shall be preserved — kept, held, brought through — by his marvelous power, for whosoever did not doubt. The promise was never that faith spares the body pain. The promise was that God preserves the faithful through the pain, and Helaman has the wounds of two hundred fainting sons to prove that the preservation is real precisely because the pain was real.

There is deep comfort here for every believer who has been taught a thinner gospel. The sons were not delivered from the battle; they were delivered in it. They bled; they fainted; they bore many wounds — and they were kept. This is what God's deliverance usually looks like in a fallen world: not the absence of wounds, but the keeping of the soul through them. And Helaman seals it with a portrait of the kind of faith that is so kept: they are young, and their minds are firm, and they do put their trust in God continually (v. 27). Not a faith that flares in crisis and fades, but a continual trust, a firmness of mind sustained day after day — the steady, undivided confidence that, when the wounds came, did not break.

Gid's report, and the rest of God (verses 28–36)

Now it came to pass that when I, Helaman, had heard these words of Gid, I was filled with exceeding joy because of the goodness of God in preserving us, that we might not all perish; yea, and I trust that the souls of them who have been slain have entered into the rest of their God. — Alma 57:36

The chapter closes with Gid's account of the escorted prisoners — who, hearing that the Lamanite armies were marching on Cumeni, took courage and rose in rebellion, ran upon the Nephite swords, and were mostly slain or scattered (vv. 30–34) — and with Gid's band returning in time to help save the city. It is another grim necessity, more death, more blood. And Helaman's response to the whole of it is the note the chapter ends on, and it gathers both of the chapter's truths into one sentence. First, joy at the preservation: the goodness of God in preserving us, that we might not all perish. And then, in the same breath, peace about the dead: I trust that the souls of them who have been slain have entered into the rest of their God. Helaman holds both at once, exactly as he did in Alma 56. He rejoices that his two thousand and sixty were kept; and he trusts that the thousand who fell are at rest in God. He does not let the miracle of the living make him forget the dead, nor does he let the death of the many shake his trust in the goodness that preserved the few. The faithful living are preserved; the faithful dead are at rest; and the same God holds them both. This is the mature faith the whole epistle has been teaching — a faith that can look at a battlefield of the slain and the spared together and call the God over all of it good.

How the chapter is built

Alma 57 is built to deepen, and to make undoubtable, the miracle Alma 56 began — and it does so by raising the cost. The two chapters are a deliberate pair, and the difference between them is the whole point. In Alma 56 the sons fought and not one had fallen to the earth (56:56) — clean, untouched, a wonder that a skeptic might still explain away. So Mormon, preserving Helaman's letter, lets the second battle answer the first by making the preservation far harder to dismiss: this time every one of the sons is wounded, two hundred faint from blood loss, the army around them is breaking, Antipus is dead and a thousand brethren are slain — and still not one of the two thousand and sixty perishes. The architecture is a deliberate escalation: same miracle, vastly higher cost, so that the explanation of luck collapses under the weight of the wounds. Helaman builds toward verse 25 by first walking us through the grimness — the rebelling prisoners cut down, the desperate counterattack, the real death all around — precisely so that when the count comes and not one son is dead, there is nowhere left to put the fact except where Helaman puts it: the miraculous power of God.

And the chapter is built to define what that miraculous deliverance actually is, against the thinner thing believers are tempted to hope for. A shallow faith hears if they did not doubt, God would deliver them and imagines exemption — no wounds, no pain, no cost. Helaman's chapter dismantles that hope verse by verse: the sons are wounded, every one; two hundred bleed to fainting; all of them suffer. The deliverance is not from the wounds but through them. And the chapter welds this hard-won understanding to its companion truth about obedience: the faith that is so preserved is not a passive feeling but an active, exact, trusting obedience — every word of command with exactness. Mormon places the doctrine (v. 21) before the miracle (v. 25) so the reader sees the order rightly: the exact, faithful obedience first, the preservation answering it, according to their faith. The two cornerstone battles together teach what neither could alone — that God's keeping of the faithful is real and countable, and that it does not lift them out of the world's wounds but holds their souls through them. The sons kept every command; not one soul of them was lost. The keepers were kept. That is the whole architecture, and the whole gospel of it.