Scriptural Savant

Home / Scripture / Book of Mormon / 3 Nephi

3 Nephi 4

Hosanna to the Most High God — The Robbers Broken and the Song of Deliverance

3 Nephi 4: the war's climax. The gathered Nephites have starved the robbers of plunder — the land left desolate, the flocks and provisions all drawn into one body with seven years' supply. Forced to fight or perish, Giddianhi marches up in the nineteenth year with a terrifying army: girded as robbers, dyed in blood, heads shorn, lamb-skins about their loins. The Nephites fall to the earth — but in supplication, not fear — and rise to meet them 'in the strength of the Lord.' The slaughter is the greatest since Lehi left Jerusalem, but the Nephites prevail; Giddianhi himself, fighting boldly, is overtaken and slain. Two years later a new leader, Zemnarihah, lays siege — but the siege starves the besiegers, not the besieged, and when the robbers try to withdraw, Gidgiddoni cuts off their retreat front and rear; thousands surrender, the rest are slain, and Zemnarihah is hanged upon a tree, the tree then felled to the earth with a cry that all who seek to destroy God's people by secret combinations be likewise felled. Then the gathered people break forth as one in song, weeping for joy, crying 'Hosanna to the Most High God' and 'Blessed be the name of the Lord God Almighty,' and praising the God of Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob for delivering them — knowing it was because of their repentance and humility that they were saved from everlasting destruction. The chapter is the vindication of the strategy of chapter 3: the patient, gathered, repentant, waiting people delivered in the strength of the Lord, their fear turned to the great cry of salvation — Hosanna.

Open printable insert (PDF) ↗Scripture only →

Where we are

This is the payoff chapter — the moment the patient, counterintuitive strategy of chapter 3 is vindicated, and a people who refused both surrender and aggression are delivered exactly as their prophet-general promised. And Mormon ends it not with a military report but with a song — the whole gathered nation breaking forth, weeping for joy, crying Hosanna to the Most High God (v. 32). That ending is the key to the chapter. The victory matters, but what Mormon wants us to feel is the deliverance — the overwhelming gratitude of a people who knew they had been saved not by their own strength but by the goodness of God, and who responded the only way a delivered people can: with a cry of praise that is, at its root, the cry save now, turned into thanksgiving for the salvation already given.

But before the song, the strategy proves itself, and the genius of it is worth seeing. The Nephites had gathered everything into one place — all their flocks, herds, provisions, the whole population — leaving the surrounding lands desolate (v. 3). This looked like retreat. It was actually a trap. Because the robbers lived by plunder, and now there was nothing to plunder: there was no chance for the robbers to plunder and to obtain food, save it were to come up in open battle against the Nephites (v. 4). The gathered people had reserved seven years' provisions; the robbers had only what they could hunt in the wilderness, and the game was running out (v. 20). So the very strategy that looked passive — gather, fortify, wait — was slowly starving the enemy, forcing him to do the one thing that would defeat him: come out and fight a prepared, provisioned, unified people on their own ground. Gidgiddoni's we will wait till they shall come against us (3 Ne. 3:21) was not timidity; it was the patient setting of a trap that the enemy's own hunger would spring. The waiting was the weapon.

And when the battle finally comes, the contrast of the two armies tells the whole spiritual story. Giddianhi's robbers come up great and terrible, girded for war, dyed in blood, and their heads were shorn, and they had head-plates upon them (v. 7) — a deliberately horrifying spectacle, designed to terrify. And the Nephites, seeing this terrible army, fall to the earth (v. 8). The robbers shout for joy, supposing the Nephites have fallen with fear (v. 9). But they have completely misread what they are seeing. In this thing they were disappointed, for the Nephites did not fear them; but they did fear their God and did supplicate him for protection (v. 10). The Nephites fell to the earth not in terror but in prayer — the same posture, opposite meaning. They dropped to the ground to cry to God, and rose up in the strength of the Lord (v. 10) to meet the charge. This is one of the most quietly powerful images in the war record: an army that responds to the terror of the enemy by falling on its face before God, and then standing up unafraid. The robbers trusted their terrifying appearance; the Nephites trusted their God; and the difference decided the battle before it was joined.

The chapter has three movements.

  1. The starved enemy forced to fight (vv. 1–10). The gathered, provisioned Nephites have left the land desolate; the robbers, unable to plunder, must attack; Giddianhi's terrible army comes up, the Nephites fall in prayer not fear, and rise in the strength of the Lord.
  2. Giddianhi broken, the siege reversed (vv. 11–27). The greatest slaughter since Lehi prevails for the Nephites; Giddianhi is slain; Zemnarihah's later siege starves the besiegers; Gidgiddoni cuts off their retreat front and rear, and the robbers surrender or fall.
  3. Zemnarihah felled, and the song of deliverance (vv. 28–33). Zemnarihah is hanged and the tree felled with a cry against all secret combinations; the gathered people break forth as one in song, weeping for joy, crying Hosanna and blessing the God of Abraham for their deliverance.

The verses to carry are these. Verse 10 names the secret of the victory — they did fear their God and did supplicate him for protection... in the strength of the Lord they did receive them. Verse 32 names the response — Hosanna to the Most High God. And verse 33 names the understanding — they knew it was because of their repentance and their humility that they had been delivered from an everlasting destruction. The chapter exists to vindicate the strategy of waiting on the Lord, to show a people delivered not by their own might but by God in answer to repentance and prayer, and to turn the whole deliverance into a song — the cry save now become the shout of the saved.

The starved enemy forced to fight (verses 1–10)

But in this thing they were disappointed, for the Nephites did not fear them; but they did fear their God and did supplicate him for protection; therefore, when the armies of Giddianhi did rush upon them they were prepared to meet them; yea, in the strength of the Lord they did receive them. — 3 Nephi 4:10

The strategy of chapter 3 begins to bear fruit before a blow is struck. The robbers sally forth to take possession of the abandoned lands (v. 1) — and find them empty. There were no wild beasts nor game in those lands which had been deserted by the Nephites... and the robbers could not exist save it were in the wilderness, for the want of food (vv. 2–3). The Nephites had drawn everything — people, flocks, provisions — into one body, reserving seven years of supply (v. 4), and so the robbers, who lived by plunder, had nothing to take. The gathering that looked like retreat was strangling the enemy. There was no chance for the robbers to plunder and to obtain food, save it were to come up in open battle (v. 4) — exactly the fight the Nephites were prepared for and the robbers were not. Hunger, not the sword, forced Giddianhi's hand. This is the patient wisdom of Gidgiddoni's strategy vindicated: by not going out to hunt the robbers in their strongholds, the Nephites made the robbers come out and fight on Nephite terms, starved and desperate. The waiting was working.

And when Giddianhi's army finally comes, it comes to terrify. The robbers are great and terrible, dyed in blood, heads shorn, armored — a spectacle calculated to break the enemy's nerve before the fighting starts (v. 7). And the Nephite army, seeing this, had all fallen to the earth (v. 8). The robbers read this exactly wrong: they shout with a loud voice, because of their joy, for they had supposed that the Nephites had fallen with fear (v. 9). But the falling was not fear; it was prayer. They did not fear them; but they did fear their God and did supplicate him for protection (v. 10). Here is the deep contrast the whole chapter turns on. Two armies, two kinds of confidence: the robbers trust their terrifying appearance, their blood-dyed armor, the spectacle of their own ferocity; the Nephites trust God, dropping to the earth to cry for his protection. And the Nephites rise from their knees prepared to meet them; yea, in the strength of the Lord they did receive them (v. 10) — that great refrain of the war record, in the strength of the Lord, the borrowed strength that does not fail. The robbers' confidence was in themselves and their terror; the Nephites' confidence was in God; and the chapter is built to show that the army on its knees rose stronger than the army shouting in its own ferocity. Fear of God cast out fear of man, and a people that feared God rose unafraid to meet an army designed to make them afraid.

Giddianhi broken, and the siege that starved the besiegers (verses 11–27)

And it came to pass that the wild game became scarce in the wilderness insomuch that the robbers were about to perish with hunger... And thus it became the desire of the people of Zemnarihah to withdraw from their design. — 3 Nephi 4:20, 22

The battle is terrible — there never was known so great a slaughter among all the people of Lehi since he left Jerusalem (v. 11) — but the Nephites prevail, and the Nephites did beat them, insomuch that they did fall back (v. 12). Giddianhi himself, who had stood and fought with boldness, is pursued in his flight, and being weary because of his much fighting he was overtaken and slain (v. 14). There is a quiet justice in how Giddianhi dies — the bold robber-leader who threatened utter destruction and demanded total surrender, undone by his own weariness, overtaken and killed in flight. The man who swore his armies would let fall the sword upon you even until ye shall become extinct (3 Ne. 3:8) is himself extinguished, and thus was the end of Giddianhi the robber (v. 14).

But the war is not over. Two years later a new leader, Zemnarihah, tries a different strategy — siege (vv. 16–17). Rather than assault the gathered Nephites, he tries to hem them in, cut them off from their lands, and starve them into surrender. And here the chapter delivers its second great vindication of the gathering strategy: the siege starves the besiegers, not the besieged. The Nephites have much provision laid up in store (v. 18); the robbers have nothing save it were meat... which meat they did obtain in the wilderness (v. 19), and the game is running out (v. 20). The besieging army, not the besieged city, is the one perishing of hunger. And the Nephites, far from passive, were continually marching out by day and by night, and falling upon their armies, and cutting them off by thousands and by tens of thousands (v. 21). The trap has closed completely: the robbers who came to starve the Nephites are themselves starving, harried, and dying, until it became the desire of the people of Zemnarihah to withdraw (v. 22). And when they try to retreat, Gidgiddoni — the prophet-general, still discerning — anticipates the move, sends his armies by night to cut off the way of their retreat (v. 24), and gets beyond the robbers, so that on the morrow... they were met by the armies of the Nephites both in their front and in their rear (v. 25). The robbers are surrounded, and many thousands... did yield themselves up prisoners, the rest slain (v. 27). The patient defensive strategy, sustained through years, has utterly broken the secret combination's armies — not by aggression but by the disciplined waiting that turned the enemy's own hunger and impatience against him.

Zemnarihah felled, and the song of the delivered (verses 28–33)

Yea, they did cry: Hosanna to the Most High God. And they did cry: Blessed be the name of the Lord God Almighty, the Most High God. And their hearts were swollen with joy, unto the gushing out of many tears, because of the great goodness of God in delivering them. — 3 Nephi 4:32–33

Zemnarihah is taken and hanged upon a tree... until he was dead, and then the people fell the tree to the earth, crying that all who shall seek to slay them because of power and secret combinations be likewise felled to the earth (vv. 28–29). The felling of the tree is a deliberate, symbolic act — a public declaration that the secret combination itself, and not just its leader, is being cut down, brought low, ended. And then comes the chapter's true climax, which is not the death of the enemy but the song of the delivered. The gathered people break forth, all as one, in singing, and praising their God for the great thing which he had done for them (v. 31). They cry Hosanna to the Most High God and Blessed be the name of the Lord God Almighty (v. 32), and their hearts were swollen with joy, unto the gushing out of many tears, because of the great goodness of God in delivering them (v. 33). The whole nation, weeping and singing as one, pours out a flood of gratitude — and the word at the center of it, Hosanna, is one of the great words of scripture (the word study below opens it up): a cry that originally means save now, save, we pray, the desperate plea of the endangered — here transformed into the shout of the saved, the cry for salvation become the praise of those already delivered.

And notice the crucial understanding the chapter ends on, in verse 33: they knew it was because of their repentance and their humility that they had been delivered from an everlasting destruction. They did not credit their fortifications, their provisions, their numbers, or even their strategy. They knew the deliverance was because of their repentance and their humility — that the war was won, finally, not on the battlefield but in the heart, when they repented and humbled themselves and cried to God. This is the whole lesson of the Lachoneus-Gidgiddoni arc sealed in a single verse: the strongest defense was a clean heart, the decisive weapon was repentance, and the deliverance came from God in answer to a humbled people. They invoke the God of Abraham, and the God of Isaac, and the God of Jacob (v. 30) — anchoring their deliverance in the covenant God of their fathers — and they ask that he protect this people in righteousness, so long as they shall call on the name of their God (v. 30). Even in triumph they understand the condition: protected so long as they call on God, in righteousness. The song of deliverance is also a vow of dependence — a people who know they were saved by grace, and who pray to keep faith with the God who saved them. Mormon ends the war not with a victor's boast but with a saved people's tears and their Hosanna — the cry of those who pleaded save now and lived to sing that they had been saved.

How the chapter is built

3 Nephi 4 is built as the vindication of chapter 3, structured so that every element of the victory traces directly back to the strategy of repentance, gathering, and waiting. Mormon constructs the battle narrative to make the reasons for the triumph unmistakable: the gathered, provisioned people starve the robbers (vv. 1–4); the praying people rise in the strength of the Lord (vv. 8–10); the patient defenders let the siege starve the besiegers (vv. 18–21); the prophet-general's discernment cuts off the retreat (vv. 24–25). At every turn the victory comes not from aggression or superior force but from the disciplined, faithful, defensive obedience to Gidgiddoni's hard counsel to wait. And the architecture drives toward a single interpretive verse — they knew it was because of their repentance and their humility that they had been delivered from an everlasting destruction (v. 33) — so that the whole military narrative is finally framed as a spiritual deliverance. Mormon builds the chapter so that the reader cannot credit the win to walls or weapons; the people themselves credit it to repentance, and the structure of the chapter agrees with them.

And the chapter is built to climax not in slaughter but in song, and the placement of the Hosanna is the key to its meaning. Mormon could have ended on the defeat of the robbers; instead he ends on the whole nation breaking forth as one in singing, weeping for joy, crying Hosanna to the Most High God. This is a deliberate structural choice that transforms a war story into a deliverance hymn. By ending on the festal cry of salvation — Hosanna, "save now," the plea of the endangered become the praise of the saved — Mormon connects this deliverance to the whole biblical pattern of God's rescues sung back to him in thanksgiving, and points forward to the greater Hosanna that will ring out when the risen Christ descends among this very people (3 Ne. 11). The chapter is constructed as a rehearsal for that coming day: a people delivered from destruction, gathered in one place, repentant and humble, crying Hosanna and Blessed be the name of the Lord — exactly the posture and the very words with which they will, a few chapters hence, greet their descending God. Mormon builds the victory over the robbers as the prelude to the visit of Christ, so that the song of deliverance here becomes the warm-up for the song of adoration there. The robbers broken, the secret combination felled like Zemnarihah's tree, the land cleansed, the people gathered and singing — the stage is being set, and the Hosanna that ends the war is the first note of the worship that will greet the Lord.